The big news in New Canaan right now is tomorrow afternoon’s CIAC Class MM final against East Lyme and the Rams’ attempt at winning a fourth straight state title.
Running a close second has been the growing talk that Turner Baty, the quarterback who transferred to New Canaan from Florida the week before the season, is going to return to Florida sometime soon after tomorrow’s game.
When I spoke to Chris “Mad Dog” Russo Monday afternoon about something else, the New Canaan resident brought up the subject. Tony Pavia, the principal at the school, initiated a conversation about it in the pressbox during the Rams’ state semifinal game on Tuesday.
The two people who are getting the biggest hits right now are Lou Marinelli, the Rams’ coach, and Terry Hanratty, the former Notre Dame and Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback, whose son, Conor, is a highly touted offensive tackle on the team and a top college recruit.
I just got off the phone with both of them.
First an overview of the situation. Baty lived in California, moved to Florida earlier this year, and then to New Canaan. And that has prompted talk that New Canaan, Marinelli and Hanratty, who said he was introduced to Baty’s father, Greg, a former NFL tight end, through a mutual contact several months ago, were part of a recruiting scheme.
Marinelli has been at New Canaan 29 years and is about to coach in his 10th state final and seventh this decade. He won his 250th career game on Thanksgiving. His track record is one of professionalism and integrity. I would find it nearly impossible to believe he would damage his reputation by bringing in a hired gun. He already had a good quarterback in Willie Ouellette and was not in need of a starter. I can’t believe he would have gone out and found one even if he did.
There was another quarterback from Arkansas earlier this year who moved to New Canaan and took part in spring practice. He ended up moving back to Arkansas because he was a fish out of water in a faster-paced town from which he was accustomed.
“For 28 years up to this point I’ve never had to deal with anything like this,” Marinelli said. “At this point I’m going to start recruiting? All I do is my best to put the best football team on the field. I can’t control what people say. My reputation is not built on wins, but helping kids.”
Hanratty, at least based on comments made on this blog, is getting the most criticism. He said his relationship with Greg Baty developed through someone who knew that both men had sons who are top college recruits. When I asked him about his role, if any, in helping Turner coming to New Canaan, Hanratty said the Batys were not happy in Florida and looking for another place to move to and inquired about New Canaan.
“Until you know the whole story, it’s very difficult to make an opinion,” Hanratty said. “This was a Baty family move, not a Turner Baty move. They also have two other kids, and I told them how outstanding the athletics and academics are here.”
I can also tell you this: Pavia and New Canaan athletic director Jay Egan would never sign off on having an athlete attend their school under the alleged circumstances.
If Baty does indeed move sometime after the season, it is going to be a public relations nightmare for everyone involved. No one will come out of this looking good. Marinelli, Hanratty, Egan and Pavia are going to be perceived as having been complicit in bringing in a football player to help win games.
But there would be another loser no one is talking about: Turner Baty. If I was a college coach recruiting him, one of my first questions would be “You moved from California, to Florida, to Connecticut and back to Florida all within a year. Why should I believe you are going to stay here?”
And while I expect this situation to be viewed from a cynicial prism, if Baty ends up moving, it is just as possible he will have lied about his situation and that a lot of innocent people were duped.
Right now all the talk about Baty’s departure is a rumor, albeit one running wild. If New Canaan wins tomorrow, there is going to be a lot of celebrating.
If Baty leaves town sometime thereafter, those cheers are going to turn to angry cries. And, either by perception or fact, there will be no winners.